top of page

Hotels vs. Airbnb in Florence, Italy: Pros, Cons, and Strategies for Unbeatable Deals

Updated: Nov 10, 2023

Florence Italy lodging

When planning your dream trip to Florence, Italy, one of the most crucial decisions you'll need to make is where to stay. Do you book a hotel room with its streamlined conveniences, or do you opt for a more immersive experience with Airbnb? To help you decide, we're delving into the pros and cons of both options and sharing some tips to secure the best deals possible.

Hotels: Classic Comfort and Convenience


Service and Amenities: Hotels typically provide an array of services such as daily housekeeping, room service, and front desk assistance around the clock. Also, amenities like gyms, restaurants, and pools are often available.

Consistency: Hotels adhere to a standardized level of quality, so you know what to expect, making your stay relatively stress-free.

Safety: Hotels have security measures in place, such as surveillance cameras and onsite security personnel.


Less Personalized: The hotel experience can feel somewhat impersonal, often lacking the homely ambiance many travelers seek.

Price: Hotels, particularly in high-demand areas of Florence, like near the Duomo or Uffizi Gallery, can be quite expensive.

Limited Local Experience: Hotels might not provide the local, immersive experience that some travelers desire.

A view of the Ponte Vecchio in Florence Italy

Airbnb: A Taste of Local Life


Variety of Options: From a room in a shared apartment to an entire villa overlooking the Tuscan hills, Airbnb offers a wide range of accommodations.

Local Experience: Airbnb allows you to live like a local, often in residential neighborhoods away from the tourist crowds, giving you an authentic glimpse into Florentine life.

Kitchen Facilities: Most Airbnb rentals come with fully equipped kitchens, helping you save money on meals and enjoy local produce and delicacies.


Quality Inconsistencies: While many hosts strive to provide the best experience, the quality can vary widely from one listing to another.

Less Instant Service: Unlike hotels, immediate help (like front desk service) may not be available in an Airbnb.

Potential Security Concerns: While Airbnb has made strides in user safety, it may lack some of the established security protocols found in hotels.

A beautiful skyline view of Florence Italy

Getting the Best Deals

Whether you opt for a hotel or an Airbnb, here are a few tips to secure the best deals in Florence:

Book Early: This is especially crucial if you're traveling during the high season (April to October). Early bookings often come with lower rates.

Consider Off-Peak Travel: Traveling during the shoulder season (early spring or late fall) could help you score discounts, as demand is lower.

Location: Staying a bit outside the city center or across the Arno river in less touristy neighborhoods could be less costly, and Florence’s excellent public transport makes it easy to reach main attractions.

Loyalty Programs and Direct Booking: Hotels often provide discounts for direct booking or for being part of their loyalty program.

Extended Stay: Airbnb hosts often offer discounts for longer stays, usually a week or more.

Negotiate: It never hurts to ask for a better deal. Some Airbnb hosts may be willing to negotiate, especially during off-peak seasons.

Ultimately, the decision between a hotel and an Airbnb in Florence comes down to your personal preferences and priorities. Each offers its unique set of advantages and can contribute to making your Tuscan adventure a memorable one. Happy traveling!



bottom of page